Sheet Mulching with Cardboard-Do's and Don'ts (2024)

UC Cooperative Extension County Master Gardeners (Solano & Yolo) are currently renovating the 900 square foot Willis Linn Jepson Native Plant Garden at the Peña Adobe in Vacaville. We have been working in many phases, involving clearing weeds out and preparing the space and soil for adding new plants. The most recent phase consisted of ‘sheet mulching' the area using cardboard.

According to the (UCIPM), ‘sheet mulching with cardboard or the heavy paper is sometimes applied as mulch and can be inexpensive and relatively easy to apply. Sheet mulching can decrease weed growth until a newly planted ground cover fills in open spaces and grows enough to shade or crowd out weeds.'

Along with reducing weed growth in the garden, cardboard has many other advantages, such as adding organic matter to the soil when it decomposes, improving the garden's drainage, and boosting nutrient levels. Also, earthworms are very attracted to the cardboard and are great for the garden, since their movement through soil increases aeration, nutrient cycling, and water infusion. The earthworm ‘castings' manure (worm poop) provides an organic type of fertilizer that offers many beneficial nutrients for plants.

To get the garden ready for the cardboard sheet mulch at the Peña garden, we removed the weeds as much as possible. If the soil is in poor condition, there is abundant literature that includes the advice of adding healthy compost, like horse manure, prior to installing the cardboard. It was not necessary to add the manure since the soil is already in good condition.

With the help of veteran Master Gardeners, we took the following steps to install the cardboard sheet mulching. We did encounter some ‘lessons learned' on the job, so I am also including some handy “do's and don'ts” to the list:

  • Get large pieces of cardboard! As you can see in the pictures, we did use some small boxes that took longer to position than it would have if we used larger cardboard pieces. We had a donation of many smaller home delivery boxes and made the best with what we had, even though it took the extra time to install.
  • Cut the cardboard along the seam and unfold it into one large piece.
  • Try to remove tape and labels, if possible, but any remnants can be later removed when the cardboard decomposes in the garden.
  • Hose down the garden area with the cardboard to help with the decomposition process.
  • We will be adding a top layer of mulch in a few weeks, so for the interim, we needed to secure the cardboard to the ground with 8” garden stakes, pounding them in with rubber mallets. We used the 8” stakes because sometimes the smaller stakes do not penetrate the ground enough to hold the cardboard in place.
  • Don't hammer the stakes in too hard! We found that if we hammered the stakes in too deep, they would just break through the cardboard.
  • The stakes can easily bend, so hold the stake at the bottom when pounding to reduce the chance of bending.
  • Sometimes you will be dealing with large roots or extremely hard soil, making it difficult to pound in the stakes. If the soil is hard, soak the area prior to putting the cardboard down. If the stake won't go all the way in because of roots, don't fret too much - they usually still stay in place if you get the stakes partially into the ground.
  • Start from one end of the garden to the other and avoid stepping on the cardboard and risking damage to the cover, since we discovered that it was easy to create holes in the cardboard.
  • Overlap the cardboard pieces by 6 to 8 inches and make sure to cover the cardboard flaps. We initially did not overlap and cover holes as much as we should have, mostly because we were running out of cardboard. A few weeks later we discovered weeds and grass gingerly growing through the tiniest holes and gaps in the cardboard, lesson learned! So, we pulled the weeds and grass out and put more cardboard down, overlapping as much as we could.

We probably used more stakes than necessary, but I think it all worked out well. A couple of days after we installed the cardboard, we had a few days of extremely high winds in the area. I had panicked visions of cardboard flying all over the Pena Adobe area and onto the freeway. The next day we went to the site and checked on our project and happily discovered that all the cardboard was secured solidly in place, hurrah!

The next steps for this beautiful garden are to add a few inches of wood chips, install the plants, set up the remaining irrigation system and create the necessary signage for the new plants. I can already visualize how the garden will look like this coming spring and am excited to continue working with my fellow Master Gardeners to make this vision a reality.

If you would like to visit the garden, take the Pena Adobe exit off I-80 West. Cross back over the freeway and turn left into the park. Take an immediate left to enter the Pena Adobe. Parking in the Pena Adobe parking lot is free (there isInsert Imagea parking fee within the main Lagoon Valley Park).

Here is a great link from UC Davis Arboretum and Public Garden on sheet mulching with cardboard: https://arboretum.ucdavis.edu/news/break-up-with-your-lawn-using-cardboard

Laying down the cardboard - P. Pashby (1)
Wetting down the cardboard prior to staking down - P. Pashby

See next page for another picture:

Ready for Mulch - P. Pashby
Sheet Mulching with Cardboard-Do's and Don'ts (2024)

FAQs

Is it a good idea to put cardboard under mulch? ›

Using cardboard or newspaper as a natural weed barrier can allow you to kill a very large area of weeds and grass without using any chemicals or herbicides. Cardboard is applied to the area. Then a layer of mulch goes on top of that. In creating a highly fertile site, a gardener may put several layers of materials.

How many layers of cardboard for sheet mulching? ›

Ensure good drainage by "popping” or loosening the soil underneath the bed with a spading fork. Remove any pernicious or persistent weeds such as blackberry, bindweed, morning glory or quackgrass. Sheet composting may not smother these weeds. Cover the ground with 4 to 6 overlapping layers of newspaper or cardboard.

Can you plant immediately after sheet mulching? ›

If you sheet mulch and want to plant immediately, it's easy. Push back the mulch and cut an X in the barrier layer. Then dig a hole in the soil and add compost. You can plant your transplants or seeds into the hole.

What are the cons of cardboard in the garden? ›

A: In addition to interfering with water and gas movement into the soil environment, corrugated cardboard has chemical contaminants that you really don't want in your soil or even your compost pile.

Does cardboard under mulch attract termites? ›

In published comparison studies, other mulch choices generally outperform cardboard in terms of plant growth, weed control, etc. But there's one area where cardboard is tops compared to every other mulch material tested. Termites. Termites LOVE cardboard.

What is the main disadvantage of sheet mulching? ›

They tend to hinder to air and water movement, most especially in unmanaged landscapes like restoration sites. A classic example is the use of cardboard or newspaper covered with wood chips. The chips are easily dislodged, exposing the sheet mulch which quickly dries out and becomes hydrophobic.

How long does it take for sheet mulching to work? ›

Decomposition takes several months, so it's best to sheet mulch an area months in advance of fall planting season. Given time and summer heat, the layers of paper and organic materials will smother the grass and all of it will decompose into wonderfully rich and fertile soil.

How do you speed up sheet mulching? ›

Water thoroughly between each layer to slow down evaporation and speed up decomposition. Sprinkle compost over each layer of cardboard and newspaper to add nitrogen and beneficial microorganisms to the mix. This helps break down the layers quickly, delivering usable resources into the soil.

Can I plant on top of sheet mulch? ›

Sheet mulching is basically a layered mulch system. First you place a biodegradable weed barrier such as recycled cardboard on top of mowed or flattened weeds or grass. Then you layer compost and mulch on top of the cardboard. You can plant trees, shrubs, perennials and annuals right through the sheet mulch.

Should you water right after mulching? ›

You should spread your mulch to be two to four inches thick. If your mulch is too thin, then weeds can push through. If your mulch is too thick, it prevents water from reaching the soil. Water after mulching — This is an optional step, but a final watering can help settle the mulch into place.

Why are my plants dying after mulching? ›

Suffocation of the roots is the most common cause of tree and shrub death from over-mulching. Repeated applications of mulch in areas with high precipitation or high irrigation can contribute to waterlogged conditions.

What plants don't like mulch? ›

There are some species that tolerate excessive mulch better than others. Some of the worst effected plants are grassy plants (iris, daylilies, liriope, etc.), Indian Hawthorn, Azaleas and Loropetalum.

Should I put anything under my mulch? ›

Don't Assume You Need Something Underneath

If you use an organic mulch that will break down, like shredded hardwood bark, avoid landscape fabric because you want the mulch to be in contact with the soil to improve it, Day says.

Is cardboard better than landscape fabric? ›

Cardboard weed barriers are a better option for vegetable gardens where crop rotation necessitates that the plants in the plot be moved around regularly to combat plant pathogens in the soil. Many larger vegetable plants also have deep roots that you would have to cut a landscaping fabric to allow for.

Will roots grow through cardboard? ›

Yes, roots can grow through cardboard, but only in certain conditions.

How long does it take to smother weeds with cardboard? ›

Cardboard vs.

Silage tarps prevent weeds and usually create a sterile seedbed in about 3 weeks in hot weather, but can take up to 6 weeks in the cooler weather. They are a bit less time-consuming, and I have used them before in our pasture or other large spaces that I just don't have enough cardboard to cover.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kimberely Baumbach CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6190

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kimberely Baumbach CPA

Birthday: 1996-01-14

Address: 8381 Boyce Course, Imeldachester, ND 74681

Phone: +3571286597580

Job: Product Banking Analyst

Hobby: Cosplaying, Inline skating, Amateur radio, Baton twirling, Mountaineering, Flying, Archery

Introduction: My name is Kimberely Baumbach CPA, I am a gorgeous, bright, charming, encouraging, zealous, lively, good person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.