It takes a lot of plants to clean the air.
ANASA study in 1989 found some interesting results when exposing plants to the air pollution chemicals known as volatile organic compounds (VOCs). It seemed that the plants in combination with the soil and soil microbes could reduce the amount of VOCs in the air. The findings were exciting because plants are more attractive, sustainable, and self-replicating than any air cleaning technology we could imagine.
However, looking closer at this study from more than 30 years ago it appears that the authors of the NASA study, and a few researchers since then, may haveoverstated the impact indoor potted plants have on air quality. More recent research has been indicating thatyou would need an impractical number of houseplants to make any difference.
Apparently we need to be outnumbered by plants indoors just the same as we are outdoors. From a visual perspective, much more than20% visible vegetation can be distracting or overwhelming, so using plants to clean the air might just not be efficient. But let’s take a look at the available research on how plants interact with different pollutants and how manyplants are needed to purify air.
Do plants remove VOCs?
An infamous review article in Nature from 2020 titled “Potted plants do not improve indoor air quality: a review and analysis of reported VOC removal efficiencies” by Bryan Cummings and Michael Waring at Drexel University looked at196 different VOC removal tests with plants across 12 different published papers. Cummings and Waring pointed out several problems with the methods of the papers they reviewed, including using sterile sealed chambers just large enough to fit the plant alone and injecting the VOCs once and allowing the plant to sit with them. In the real world, indoor plants are in large rooms with people, furniture, building materials, and continuous sources of VOCs.
The term VOC refers to a very wide variety of substances that tend to become gasses at room temperature. The pungent smells of paints, glues, lacquers, and similar products represent high concentrations of VOCs in the air, as do other strong smells like alcoholic beverages, essential oils, or new synthetic materials.Most homes have constant low levels of VOCs from new clothing, furniture, building materials, or cleaning products. In general VOCs do not have an immediate impact, but exposure over time is linked toasthma in children andformation of potentially more harmful particle pollution. Some VOCs, such asbenzene in gasoline, are considered carcinogens, so there is a lot of interest in finding ways to reduce them in the home.
Cummings and Waring found a very wide range of VOC removal rates. The impact of different VOCs was inconsistent across studies, as was the performance of different plant species. But they said that in 196 experiments, plants were able to clean an average of 0.062 cubic meters of air per plant per hour, which is only about 13% of thehalf a cubic meter we breathe at the same time.
A plant would need to clean many times the amount of air a person breathes to effectively provide air that has less pollution. But plants do have some impact, depending on their size, leaf shape, and individual characteristics, so let’s look at the studies on a few specific species.
How much pollution do arrowhead plants remove?
In one study, enough benzene to raise the concentration to250 times the safe limit was injectedinto a tiny chamber with an arrowhead plant. The chamber was then sealed for eight days. The arrowhead plant in addition to its soil was able to purify about1% of a cubic foot or a little more than a third of a liter of air an hour. The rate dropped by half when the arrowhead plant was in just water, showing that much of the removal was due to the soil and microorganisms in the soil.
By comparison in one test our Molekule Mini air purifier was able to clear toluene, a close relative of benzene, at a lower concentration but a larger amount in a much larger chamber more than 100,000 times faster.
*Removed99.7% toluene in a 30 cubic meter chamber in 8 hours from an initial concentration of 1938 μg/m3
How much pollution do Ficus plants remove?
One researcher subjectedFicus to formaldehyde aboutten times the safe limit for five hours anda relatively safe amount of toluene and xylene for 24 hours. The plants were in a medium-sized (one square meter) chamber. Interestingly, the different Ficus species did admirably at removing the large amount of formaldehyde, getting to the neighborhood of 10 cubic feet or 300 liters per hour. It is not clear if those results translate to the much lower levels typical of households or if it is sufficient to reduce the impact of formaldehyde.
Ficus benjamina, the species used to remove formaldehyde
Mini was able to remove formaldehyde more than 25 times faster, but Ficusplants just might be able to remove enough formaldehyde to matter.Plants can use airborne formaldehyde intheir metabolisms, possibly because formaldehyde is extremely simple and small. So putting a few potted Ficusor other plants around may lower the concentration of formaldehyde,but primarily during the day when they are photosynthesizing.
*Removed56.2% toluene in a 30 cubic meter chamber in 8 hours from an initial concentration of 1071 μg/m3
Ficus benghalensis, the species used to remove toluene and xylene
Toluene and xylene were less impressive, however, and Mini was about 600 times faster.
*Removed99.7% toluene in a 30 cubic meter chamber in 8 hours from an initial concentration of 1938 ug/m3
The plants’ metabolisms either did not have a use for the larger and more complex toluene, xylene, or benzene molecules, or could not remove them as quickly for some other reason.
Plants and particle pollution
VOCs are just one aspect of air pollution. Plants have also been tested on their ability to remove particles, like from smoke or exhaust. Particle pollution is different from VOC and other gaseous pollution because particles are typically larger than individual gas molecules and can carry morefree radicals and other reactive substances that react with your body and cause damage.
A plant can’t absorb particles and use them like they can with formaldehyde. Instead, they remove particles by just holding them on the surface of their leaves. Most research into plants and particle removal are concerned with the total surface area of a plant’s leaves. Other factors are also important, for exampleleaves with more wax or that have rougher textures can hold more particles.
A medium sizedfern orspider plant with their many long leaves have a lot of surface areas for houseplants at around 1,200 square centimeters total. By comparison our lungs have an internal surface area of 50 to 75 squaremeters, or around 500 times as much, and our lungs are constantly pulling in air with the power of our diaphragm muscles, which plants do not have. Similarly, the dense forest of fibers in an air filter offers a lot of surface area to trap particles.
How much pollution do spider plants remove?
An experiment placing spider plants in different occupied rooms for 2 months found the leaves accumulated about 2-4 times the weight of particles by area than aluminum plates in the same rooms, which means they are better than nothing. We don’t know what the air quality was like in these rooms, but the maximum amount of particles each spider plant accumulated was around 20 micrograms per square centimeter of leaf. A spider plant has somewhere around2,000 square centimeters of leaves, which makes for 50,000 micrograms per plantin 2 months (an aspirin tablet weighs 300,000-500,000 micrograms, in comparison).
When the AQI is moderate at 100, there are about9,000 micrograms of inhalable particles (PM10) in a small 250 square foot room. If the source of pollution is outside, particle pollution will be replaced at most once an hour or every fifteen minutes if the window is open.
*Estimated assuming an 8.5×11 inch aluminum plate
**Removed89% of an initial airborne dust (0.5 um to 10 um) concentration of approximately 0.2 micrograms per cubic meter was removed from a 30 cubic meter chamber in 20 minutes.
Compared to the overall amount of particles in the air, a spider plant doesn’t make much of a meaningful difference. It’s just a little less thanthe fraction of smaller particles that are deposited in your lungs, and around 1% of what is coming into a home from outside. Molekule Air Mini, by comparison, was able to remove 89% of dust particles in a small chamber in about 20 minutes.
Spider plants do look nice and are very easy to propagate so there’s no reason not to spread them around your home, and as long as the soil isn’t moldy they do not make air quality worse. They also have beenshown to remove formaldehyde in one study, though the authors have not made the full data public.
We can use the particle deposition data above to get an idea of how the presence of other plant species might remove particles.
How much pollution do aloe vera and other succulents remove?
The same study that tested spider plants and formaldehyde also mentioned that spider plantswere better at removing formaldehyde than aloe vera but without seeing the data we cannot know to what extent.
We can estimate how many particles might fall on it, however. A mature 6-month old aloe vera plant in normal soil has about12 long leaves with about 600 square centimeters per leaf. The leaves stick straight up so let’s assume all 7,200 square centimeters capture particles. Plants vary widely in the ability to capture particles, with the most effective being able to capture around75 micrograms per cubic centimeter. Let’s give aloe vera the benefit of the doubt and assume it captures particles as well as the best.
**Removed89% of an initial airborne dust (0.5 um to 10 um) concentration of approximately 0.2 micrograms per cubic meter was removed from a 30 cubic meter chamber in 20 minutes.
Even if aloe vera was particularly skilled at capturing particles, it doesn’t quite remove enough pollution to have a significant impact. At best it would remove particles similarly to a person who is out of breath.
Plants are great to have around and offer many benefits, including a tiny amount of air cleaning, but they don’t compare to an air purifier or proper ventilation. Keep an eye onthis blog and ourFacebook,Instagram, andTwitter accounts for more on the science of clean air.
