True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (2024)

6 Best Pumpkins for Carving (That You Can't Buy at Stores)

There's a lot less variety among buying whole pumpkins than any other crop in the produce department. Because pumpkins are only a seasonal specialty, locals growers and producers are not as willing to risk their profitable harvest with unique pumpkin varieties that are unproven.

Similar to other specialty herbs and crops, some of the most exotic, rare, and even ginormous competition pumpkins can only be left to the devices of the home gardener. Here are a few unique pumpkin varieties that are certain to make any Halloween a little more spooky.


Ol' Zeb's Pumpkin Seeds

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (1)

  • Pumpkin Weight: 25-30 lbs
  • Days to Carving: 105 days
  • Seeding Dates: May 15 - June 21

Ol' Zeb's pumpkins seeds grow a rare Canadian heirloom thriving in many gardens, requiring a brief 105 day growing season to produce classic and uniform 25-30 lb pumpkins. Boasts thick heirloom ridges that are just as decorative whether carved or left intact.


Harvest Jack F1 Pumpkin

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (2)

  • Pumpkin Weight: 22-28 lbs
  • Days to Carving: 105 days
  • Seeding Dates: May 15 - June 21

Harvest Jack F1 pumpkins seeds have been specially bred to produce taller, more oblong pumpkins for easy Halloween carving. While many types of winter squash, including pumpkin, are known to grow horizontal, Harvest Jack F1 offers a smoother and more upright space for carving.


New Moon Hybrid Pumpkin

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (3)

  • Pumpkin Weight: 35-45 lbs
  • Days to Carving: 110 days
  • Seeding Dates: May 15 - June 15

New Moon Hybrid pumpkins seeds grow one of the most rewarding winter squashes you could ask for. Ready to harvest in 110 days, New Moon Hybrid delivers perfectly uniform 35-45 lb alpine white pumpkins certain to turn any regular Jack O Lantern into talk of the neighborhood.


Howden Pumpkin Seeds

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (4)

  • Pumpkin Weight: 15-25 lbs
  • Days to Carving: 115 days
  • Seeding Dates: May 15 - June 15

Howden pumpkins seeds produce timeless American 15-25 lb carving pumpkins with heirloom ridges and bright orange skin. Developed in Massachusetts specifically for the Halloween season, Howden pumpkins were tailor made for carving.


Montana Jack Pumpkin

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (5)

  • Pumpkin Weight: 8-15 lbs
  • Days to Carving: 90 days
  • Seeding Dates: May 8 - July 15

Montana Jack pumpkins seeds promise a Halloween harvest for gardeners in more northern regions with shorter growing seasons. While larger pumpkins need to be sown by June, Montana Jack can be planted as late as mid-July for perfectly rounded carving pumpkins.


Casper Pumpkin Seeds

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (6)

  • Pumpkin Weight: 12-15 lbs
  • Days to Carving: 115 days
  • Seeding Dates: May 15 - June 15

Casper pumpkins seeds grow one of the most unique varieties of either pumpkin or ornamental winter squash. Grown for appearance and carving ability rather than flavor, the albino white Casper produces 12-15 lb pumpkins for a little flare in your haunted house.

True Leaf Market Seed Company | Buy Non-GMO, Heirloom, Organic Seeds (2024)

FAQs

What are the disadvantages of heirloom seeds? ›

Most heirloom seeds are more vulnerable to diseases because commercial seeds are usually bred specifically for disease resistance. Heirloom seeds also have lower yields than hybrids, which can be a disadvantage for farmers and home growers with limited space.

Are non-GMO heirloom seeds organic? ›

Heirloom seeds are produced by open-pollination carried out by pollinators like birds, bees and wind. Gardening organically with non-GMO seeds is always a better choice. Heirloom seeds, even without an organic label, are mostly chemical-free.

What is the difference between heirloom and non heirloom seeds? ›

Heirlooms are seed varieties that are at least 50 years old, and you can save these seeds and plant them year after year. Heirlooms are never hybrids or GMOs. Hybrids are crosses of heirloom varieties. If you save hybrid seeds, you won't get what you expect.

How long do organic heirloom seeds last? ›

For short-term storage, such as for next year's garden, storing the seed jar in a cool, dark, moisture-free environment is sufficient. Heirloom seeds stored this way will last for 3-5 years. For longer storage, place the jar in the refrigerator and the seeds should be good for 10-15 years.

Why are heirloom seeds harder to grow? ›

Heirlooms evolved long before resistance to genetic disease or insects was possible. Take, for example, the Brandywine tomato, an heirloom that has probably the best flavor of any variety but can be a challenge to grow. It lacks disease resistance, making it susceptible to wilt that can wipe out the crop.

Are heirloom seeds better than regular seeds? ›

Heirloom seeds are easy to find and cost about the same as other seeds. But these older, tried-and-true varieties open up a world of rich flavors, unique colors, and other outstanding characteristics that make them the treasures they are.

Can you buy seeds that are not genetically modified? ›

The “USDA ORGANIC” label on seed packets assures gardeners the seeds were grown without the use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides or genetically engineered seeds and materials. Treated seeds are those coated with a chemical, like a fungicide or pesticide.

Is heirloom or organic better? ›

Gardening organically goes hand in hand with growing heirlooms, since many were introduced before synthetic fertilizers and pesticides became available. But heirloom does not guarantee produce was raised without chemicals, making organic a better choice when you're worried about toxins.

Does it matter if my seeds are organic? ›

It's easy to understand why organically-grown seed will be more resilient in your garden – doing a better job of fending off pests and diseases and providing great yield without much help. They have been generationally bred to do that.

What to look for when buying heirloom seeds? ›

Some say that a true heirloom seed must be from a fruit, flower, or vegetable grown before World War II. Heirloom plants are “open-pollinated” which means this occurs by wind or insects without human assistance. They are never genetically modified organisms (GMO).

Why do people want heirloom seeds? ›

Gardening with heirloom seeds has unique benefits, as these plants are regionally adapted and can be passed down from generation to generation. Growing heirloom varieties can help preserve history and plant diversity, in addition to providing superior flavor and nutrition compared to hybrids.

Are burpee seeds heirloom? ›

Burpee is proud to have bred a number of heirlooms that are favorites to this day. 'Burpee's Stringless Green Pod' bush beans date all the way back in 1894, and the crisp, juicy, and super-flavorful variety is still going strong.

Should you store seeds in the fridge or freezer? ›

Keep seeds out of direct sunlight in a cool spot that maintains a fairly consistent temperature. Consider a cold closet, a basem*nt, or a room on the north side of your home that remains cool year round. Freezing isn't necessary for short-term storage, but you can refrigerate seeds, provided they are sufficiently dry.

Should I freeze my heirloom seeds? ›

Freezer storage is an option and a good one if you have seeds that you know will be in there for longer than a season. The freezer will ensure that your seed remains dormant but can be risky if you lose power or plan to take them out often for inventory or planting.

Will 20 year old seeds grow? ›

The truth is seeds don't expire. They lose viability if stored improperly. While most seed companies will tell you to replace seeds every 2-3 years, those seeds will keep for decades and will germinate when planted if kept in a cool, dark, and dry place.

What is the difference between heritage and heirloom seeds? ›

The two terms – heirloom and heritage – are interchangeable, heritage being the more colloquial British term and heirloom being the more globally recognised term and the term more often used by chefs.

Can you save seeds from non heirloom plants? ›

Technically, you can save the seeds, but they won't don't grow true to type, meaning you're likely a plant that produces very different food the second time around (if the seeds grow at all).

What are the hardest seeds to save? ›

Seeds from biennial crops such as carrots or beets are harder to save since the plants need two growing seasons to set seed.

What is special about heirloom seeds? ›

Heirloom seeds, sometimes referred to as open-pollinated seeds, are genetically diverse and have been handed down from generation to generation. Typically, heirlooms have been developed over time for optimal response to their local climate and soil by virtue of being hand-selected for particular traits.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duncan Muller

Last Updated:

Views: 6361

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duncan Muller

Birthday: 1997-01-13

Address: Apt. 505 914 Phillip Crossroad, O'Konborough, NV 62411

Phone: +8555305800947

Job: Construction Agent

Hobby: Shopping, Table tennis, Snowboarding, Rafting, Motor sports, Homebrewing, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Duncan Muller, I am a enchanting, good, gentle, modern, tasty, nice, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.